principals – 麻豆精品 America's Education News Source Fri, 21 Nov 2025 15:40:12 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.7.2 /wp-content/uploads/2022/05/cropped-74_favicon-32x32.png principals – 麻豆精品 32 32 Opinion: Stop Ignoring the Leaders Who Can Transform High Schools /article/stop-ignoring-the-leaders-who-can-transform-high-schools/ Fri, 21 Nov 2025 15:30:00 +0000 /?post_type=article&p=1023732 Amid growing calls for redefining the high school experience, there鈥檚 a critical missing link that is often overlooked: principals and assistant principals. Despite their influence over how time is used, which courses are offered, how teachers and counselors collaborate, and which business and college partners can engage with students, most school administrators simply aren鈥檛 trained, supported or held accountable for transforming their high schools. 

Their preparation and evaluation focuses disproportionately on compliance and core academics, not on whether students graduate ready for what comes next. The result is a system that sidelines the very leaders who could drive change. School-level leaders should be the chief architects of high school redesign and high-quality pathways, connecting what students learn in classrooms with the real skills, experiences and credentials they鈥檒l need after graduation. 


Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for 麻豆精品 Newsletter


Decades of research confirm what common sense suggests: Effective principals and assistant principals drive student success. The has shown that principals are second only to teachers on their impact on student learning. More recent from the UChicago Consortium on School Research finds strong school leaders affect not only high school achievement but also students鈥 college enrollment and persistence.   

These findings are especially relevant now as educators and policymakers across the country rethink the purpose and structure of high school.  New efforts from the, the , and aim to align education with the demands of today鈥檚 economy 鈥 emphasizing skills, credentials, and experiences that prepare students for college, career and adult life. But these initiatives will falter if the people responsible for running high schools aren鈥檛 prepared.

Despite the key role they play,  principals rarely receive the training or guidance needed to lead this kind of redesign and must simultaneously manage competing district priorities.  of district leaders consistently rank math and reading scores, chronic absenteeism and teacher recruitment as top concerns, while expanding access to career and technical education or dual enrollment programs ranks near the bottom. 

The message seems to be that academic recovery matters, but preparing students for life after graduation is optional. As a result, high school redesign efforts often sit on the margins, disconnected from the day-to-day work of teaching and learning. Principals, pressed by urgent academic demands, lack the time, resources, or cover  to connect those priorities with students鈥 long-term goals.

If states and districts want high school redesign to succeed, they need to put principals and assistant principals at the center of those efforts. This means aligning preparation, expectations, and accountability around the idea that postsecondary readiness is not a separate responsibility but a core part of the work of principals and assistant principals. 

First, it鈥檚 important to break down the silos separating high school redesign from broader school improvement priorities.  Postsecondary readiness is school improvement. Focusing on instructional achievement isn鈥檛 mutually exclusive with improving career-connected learning or access to accelerated coursework.  

Matt Gandal, President of Education Strategy Group recently , 鈥淚f we want to change the trajectory of student performance in high school, we have to do more to inspire them 鈥 including showing them the connection between what they鈥檙e learning in school and their future goals.鈥 Vermont has developed a framework that shows how this is possible by including mechanisms to help principals and assistant principals plan for increasing access to advanced coursework. 

Second, pathway planning, counselor supervision and high-quality advising need to be part of state school leader standards.  Across states, school leadership standards rarely reference or outline the specific knowledge and skills that secondary principals should develop in order to effectively lead students to postsecondary and workforce success. When these outcomes become part of what schools are held accountable for, principals can lead them with purpose.  Illinois鈥 offers a strong model by explicitly including college and career readiness as a leadership competency.  

Third, and most critical, the initial preparation, ongoing coaching and peer networks for school leaders should all emphasize high school redesign and pathways.  Skim most state certification for principals and you鈥檒l see mandatory classes on finance, instruction, child psychology and special education law. Licensure and preparation programs should treat college and career readiness as fundamental, not elective. Principals need to learn how to align schedules, curricula and partnerships to help every student graduate with a plan and the experiences to pursue it. They deserve ongoing coaching and peer networks that reinforce this vision.

Promising models exist and show a way forward. For example, since 2021-2022, the has partnered with over 300 school and district leaders through a multi-year coaching and professional learning partnership focused on the conditions that enable postsecondary readiness. This partnership is guided by an overarching research-based for leadership development oriented toward long-term student success. 

Reframing the principal鈥檚 job around students鈥 long-term readiness offers high returns. When principals connect academic learning with meaningful experiences such as dual enrollment, apprenticeships or credential programs, students are more likely to graduate with confidence and purpose. They see school as relevant to their future, not as a disconnected series of requirements. The cost of these changes is modest compared with their potential benefits. The estimates that comprehensive leadership development  can be implemented for about $42 per student. This cost is far less than the price of failed reforms. 

What鈥檚 missing is not evidence or funding but alignment: Policymakers and system leaders must decide that empowering principals to lead this work is worth the investment. High school redesign will not succeed through frameworks or pilot programs alone. It will succeed when principals have the preparation, authority and support to make postsecondary readiness central to their mission 鈥 and when states and districts create the conditions for them to do so.

Disclosure: 麻豆精品 receive financial support from the Wallace Foundation.

]]>
School Admin Unions on the Rise Since COVID, With 11 New Locals in 8 States /article/school-admin-unions-on-the-rise-since-covid-with-11-new-locals-in-8-states/ Mon, 01 Sep 2025 12:30:00 +0000 /?post_type=article&p=1020193 Jeff Litz鈥檚 30th year in Fairfax County Public Schools won鈥檛 just be spent as a high school principal, but as the new president of the district鈥檚 first administrators union. 

The is currently negotiating its first contract with the 180,000-student Virginia district. It鈥檚 one of four school administrators unions that recently formed in the state, following the lifting of a nearly . And Virginia is not alone.

Similar law changes, coupled with revisions to school policies post-COVID, have fueled an increase in the number of school administrators unions and contract negotiations nationwide.


Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for 麻豆精品 Newsletter


Since 2020, 11 new union locals have joined the , which now represents some 25,000 school and district leaders in 150 chapters across the country, said communications director Scott Treibitz. The new locals are in Denver; Portland, Oregon; Seattle; San Diego; Rochester, Minnesota; Imperial Beach, California; Frisco, Colorado; Chula Vista, California; St. Louis, Missouri; and Chester, Pennsylvania, as well as Fairfax.

Other unions, like the , have existed for decades but recently negotiated their first contracts.

Litz, who helped create the 1,400-member Fairfax County administrators union after the state law changed, has managed contract negotiations since April.

鈥淚t’s been really eye-opening for me, and over the past two or three years, I鈥檝e actually become pretty passionate about ensuring that working conditions exist so that we can really do our best work for kids,鈥 he said. 鈥淚t has been a lot of hard work, but it has been good work.鈥

Administrators unions have seen 鈥渁 huge growth spurt since the pandemic,鈥 Treibitz said. The federation’s membership was roughly 20,000 in 2020 and has grown by about 5,000, he said.

鈥淪ince COVID, there has been a foot on the [gas] pedal of school administrators to organize, and COVID played a key ingredient in that,鈥 he said. 鈥淪chool districts were changing policies, and in order to operate, they had to negotiate with teachers unions, and any other work that had to happen was dumped on principals, assistant principals and all the central office folks.鈥

The was and approved a collective bargaining agreement last year. The three-year contract includes a 4.5% cost-of-living adjustment, administrator stipends, $1,000 retention bonuses and a working group on school and leader safety, according to . 

In Minnesota, the became the state鈥檚 , in 2022. The union approved a in 2024 that includes roughly a 3.5% raise each year.

The Fairfax County administrators union was founded as a federation affiliate in 2023, after the allowed local governments to grant employee unions collective bargaining rights. The district鈥檚 teachers unions have existed for decades and were able to negotiate contracts after the law changed, but the administrators union had to be created from scratch.

In 2023, about 24% of elementary and secondary school administrators were union members, according to the . Nearly 70% of teachers were in a union in the 2020-21 school year, the latest data available from shows. On average, unionized school leaders earned roughly $500 more per week than their non-union counterparts.

The was a professional membership organization for years but was able to collectively bargain after legislation to allow the practice was signed .

鈥淔or the first time, Chicago school leaders have a guaranteed, enforceable voice in policies that directly affect their schools and students,鈥 said union President Kia Banks in a press release. 鈥淥ver the years, principals were often made the face of policies they didn鈥檛 support, left to manage failing systems and even targeted with retaliation. Many felt isolated in their roles and unappreciated in their communities, factors that negatively impacted schools.鈥

The 鈥 which still has to be approved by members and the school board 鈥 includes a retroactive 4% cost-of-living increase for the 2024-25 school year and baseline raises for the coming school year. It also creates more due-process protections for principals who face disciplinary actions.

Lack of voice and pay raises also fueled other administrator unions’ recent contract negotiations.

The is asking for higher pay to offset . It also wants more compensation for additional assigned duties and flexible scheduling when staff are required to stay after hours to address student mental health. In December, the group organized under the umbrella of the Teamsters union after they said their voices went unheard, according to the .

鈥淎dministrators remain undervalued and underpaid. Many are working 60-plus hours a week, sacrificing work-life balance and mental health, without the recognition or compensation they deserve,鈥 union President Maria Nichols wrote in an August member . 鈥淭his is not sustainable. How is it that teachers receive an hourly rate for work beyond their contracted day, while administrators 鈥 also salaried employees 鈥 receive nothing?鈥

In Pittsfield, Massachusetts, administrators at least one hour longer than their teachers each day in exchange for a 3.5% raise, in a contract approved in February. In Maryland, administrators with Prince George鈥檚 County Public Schools landed yearly raises and bonuses of up to $3,000 in a that was ratified by members in April. 

The United Administrators of San Francisco with its district in August. President Anna Klafter said school principals, supervisors and program administrators can earn up to $40,000 a year more in surrounding districts, are being tasked with extra responsibilities such as addressing student medical needs and have fewer support staff. These issues have contributed to a , according to the union. 

鈥淥ur teachers got a really big raise 鈥 which we’re very happy they did 鈥 but while [they] were able to get a 5% raise last year, we were not,鈥 she told 麻豆精品. 鈥淣ow, we have teachers who are making more than their principals, and we have potential principals and leaders who aren’t willing to go into these roles, because they wouldn’t even be making as much money as they do as teachers.鈥

The national principal turnover rate declined from a high of 16% right after the pandemic to about 8% in the 2023-24 school year, according to the 2025 . The rate is still higher than pre-pandemic levels, which were roughly 3%.

鈥淧eople don’t necessarily want to leave their jobs,鈥 Treibitz said. 鈥淭hey’re just trying to find mechanisms to help protect them and help make their job a more sturdy job, because the changes are fast and furious.鈥

]]>
Q&A: LA鈥檚 New Principal Union President Says Her Members Are Overworked /article/qa-las-new-principal-union-president-says-her-members-are-overworked/ Wed, 05 Mar 2025 11:30:00 +0000 /?post_type=article&p=1011017 Maria Nichols, leader of the principals union for the , likes to show up for contract negotiations well-prepared. 

Less than a year into her role as president of the , the former community schools administrator in December with the . 

Nichols said the move was aimed at strengthening the AALA鈥檚 bargaining power ahead of its contract negotiations with LAUSD this spring. 


Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for 麻豆精品 Newsletter


AALA is the official bargaining unit for middle-level administrators in LAUSD, including the district鈥檚 elementary and secondary principals. 

Nichols said each day her members face rising workloads, budget cuts, and threats to their safety. As a four-decade veteran of LAUSD, she knows those issues firsthand. 

鈥淔or me, it’s about changing a system,鈥 Nichols said of working with the district. 鈥淏ecause the people are not the problem.鈥

Perhaps it鈥檚 respect for the system that鈥檚 led Nichols to join the AALA with the Teamsters. She said the district has already made concessions to the AALA since the change. 

This conversation has been edited for length and clarity. 

Can you tell me more about the issues facing principals and administrators鈥 workload in LAUSD?

We represent the ability to bargain the effects of district action, whether it is positive or negative for the membership.

We鈥檙e now in the third year of superintendent Alberto Carvalho鈥檚 strategic plan, and many initiatives have been pushed out, especially at the school site or with directors and operations coordinators who supervise school sites. 

However, now, when a new initiative is introduced, the district has the responsibility to meet and bargain with us. In previous cases, that was not the case.

For example, the district required five classroom observations and formal visits per week with written feedback for every administrator at each school site. 

If you had a principal, an assistant principal, or an assistant principal for special education鈥攁nd in the bigger high schools, two or three principals鈥攅verybody had to participate in five classroom observations and then input their informal observations.

When you add 40 minutes times five, that’s an additional 200 minutes to your workload.

It wasn’t until we affiliated with Teamsters in December and submitted a demand-to-bargain letter that we basically agreed that the intent wasn’t about quotas, and that there was a lack of cohesion in implementation. Therefore, the quotas have been lifted, which is a huge win for us right now.

Why Teamsters, and why now?

When I first took on the role, I proceeded to run on three pillars.

One of them being a transformational leader. I was very aware of the conditions out there because I was in the field. I proceeded to try to build communication systems and collaborative structures with our district. But two months in, I was getting nowhere with the district.

So, in early September,  I shared my concerns and urgency with my staff because this year is a negotiating year for us. We have an urgency to try to get the best contract, and I knew that the language of the contract mattered.

I brought up the possibility of meeting with other unions to see if we could affiliate and become bigger. I knew that unions were about solidarity and power, and power means numbers and strength. Teamsters came, and they brought their whole team. All of a sudden, we had this team that could support our work, especially the legal part. We continue to have the AALA model, which is one vision and one voice together, but since affiliating, we’ve begun to bring immediate relief at the hands of our brothers and sisters.

How has budgeting played out as an issue for members of your union?

Budget development is happening right now. For example, I’m hearing from my members that they are reporting getting less psychiatric social work time, less school psychology time, less allocation for assistant principals鈥損ositions that support programs and special education. Last year, the district did away with 400 assistant principal positions. That was another area that really created urgency, that the district was doing this to us. That could have also been an area to bargain because the effects of not having an assistant principal could have been bargained. 

If the positions are being cut in half or more, that’s a great concern. In LAUSD, we rely on human capital to do the human work, and those positions right now are being slashed in addition to having less money.

Campus safety is a crucial responsibility for principals, particularly in collaboration with law enforcement partners. How does that play into the upcoming bargaining period?

Since 2020, school police have almost been completely taken out of the district, leaving very few coming back from COVID. Crimes have increased tremendously, including physical fights, guns at schools, etcetera. Safety is a huge concern.

The district talks a lot about keeping students safe, keeping employees safe, but the resources that we currently have are limited. The district implements a positive behavior support system. The district implements it for students’ progressive discipline, which is good, but for the more difficult cases, the district has these diversion tickets that kids get, and they don’t have any weight or teeth.

We want to be mindful of the students we serve and the populations and demographics they belong to, but the current systems are not enough.

This article is part of a collaboration between 麻豆精品 and the USC Annenberg School for Communication and Journalism.

]]>
N.C. Central University Offers New Scholarship for Aspiring Principals /article/n-c-central-university-offers-new-scholarship-for-aspiring-principals/ Wed, 28 Aug 2024 14:30:00 +0000 /?post_type=article&p=732175 This article was originally published in

A partnership between and North Carolina Central University (NCCU) is providing $1.5 million in scholarship funding for aspiring principals from small, high-need North Carolina school districts.

The Recruitment, Retention, and Promotion of Effective Educators scholarship initiative covers the cost of a two-year Master of School Administration degree program. This includes tuition and a salary for their full-time principal internship, which is completed during their second year. Funding for the scholarship comes from grants, one via the U.S. Department of Education and another from N.C. Department of Public Instruction.

“This partnership underscores our shared dedication to advancing educational equity and excellence and preparing our aspiring leaders to lead with integrity,  purpose, and through innovation,” NCCU MSA Program Director Portia Gibbs-Roseboro said.


Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for 麻豆精品 Newsletter


The Innovation Project is a nonprofit that connects school district leaders throughout the state with the purpose of inspiring change and equity.

Sharon Contreras, CEO of The Innovation Project, said that with strong support, great teachers can become great principals.

“The interview process was especially dynamic and illuminated those candidates with the potential to do the work our students need and deserve. I鈥檓 thrilled with the outcome and I look forward to seeing these professionals advance in their careers and continue to serve in smaller districts,鈥 Contreras said.

Candidates were selected to be in the scholarship program鈥檚 first cohort after nominations, applying, and a group interview process. The 16 scholarship recipients are listed below.

  • Cecelia Aguilar, Warren County School District
  • Trevor Beverly, Lexington City Schools
  • James Brown, Warren County School District
  • QuaShana Brown, Edgecombe County Public Schools
  • Sylvia Carver, Elizabeth City – Pasquotank Public Schools
  • Wilonda Gillespie-Cates, Vance County Public Schools
  • J’Vonn Davis, Elizabeth City – Pasquotank Public Schools
  • Megan Gentry, Mt. Airy School District
  • Pamela Jordan, Warren County School District
  • Ashley Knowles, Sampson County Schools
  • Brandon Powell, Sampson County Schools
  • Jennivise Lindsay, Vance County Public Schools
  • Kenya Raynor, Edgecombe County Public Schools
  • Elaine Reales, Mt. Airy School District
  • West Scherer, Asheboro City Schools
  • Danielle Wissner, Elizabeth City – Pasquotank Public Schools

The cohort members will begin classes in the upcoming fall semester. In addition to their course work, recipients also committed to a five-year service obligation.

This first appeared on and is republished here under a Creative Commons license.

]]>
North Carolina Principals Want Pay Scale to Go Beyond School Performance, Size /article/nc-principals-want-their-pay-scale-to-go-beyond-school-performance-and-size/ Fri, 15 Mar 2024 16:30:00 +0000 /?post_type=article&p=723855 This article was originally published in

Two of North Carolina’s 2023 Regional Principals of the Year during a House education reform meeting on Monday to revise the state’s plan for paying school principals. Among other things, two representatives from the (NCPAPA) said the current plan is too tied to test scores — discouraging some principals from serving in low-performing or high-poverty schools.

Currently, the state’s principal salary schedule is tied to Average Daily Membership (ADM) and school growth. In 2018, the state updated the principal pay scale to increase pay. On Monday, presenters Dr. John Lassiter and Ashley Faulkenberry told lawmakers that NCPAPA’s requested revisions build off that scale.

“It is not focused on significant increases in pay but on tweaking the compensation model to provide greater pay stability and to keep outstanding principals in their schools longer,” says. “The current plan was a step in the right direction for overall principal compensation. However, the plan had a few unintended consequences.”


Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for 麻豆精品 Newsletter


Those consequences, according to the presentation, include:

  • Big swings in pay based on many factors beyond the principal鈥檚 control.
  • Not considering the complexity of the school.
  • De-incentivizing outstanding assistant principals from aspiring to become principals and stay in the field.

NCPAPA’s proposed plan would add a retention bonus and include factors such as how many multi-language and students experiencing homelessness a school has, in addition to school size and performance.

“We recognize that there’s a sense of urgency to support North Carolina schools, and to ensure strong school leadership is in place. Because we know that school leadership is one of the top two leading factors impacting overall school success,” said Lassiter, the principal of in Perquimans County Schools. “Today, we want to look at adding a few complexity factors to the principal compensation plan that look at the challenging job that a principal has in a more unique way. … We’re asking to redeploy some of the resources so that there’s more stability in pay.”

Here is a look at the current principal pay plan, followed by a look at the proposal presented to lawmakers on Monday.

Not removing performance pay, but changing how its calculated

Roughly one out of five N.C. principals (21%), agree or strongly agree that performance-based pay in the current pay plan makes up a fair portion of a principal鈥檚 total salary, according to a NCPAPA survey.

The current growth score metric also does not factor in scores on science and history tests, the presentation said, or exam scores in career and technical education and dual-enrollment courses.

“We don’t recommend removing performance pay from principal compensation. We know that it’s an important part of the work that we do,” Lassiter told lawmakers. “But we do want to share that the majority of principles are saying that it’s not a fair portion of how they’re compensated.”

Currently, principals get an additional 10% if they meet EVAAS growth targets and 20% for exceeding that target. The principals’ plan presented on Monday calls for reducing that to 5% and 10%, respectively.

The money not spent on growth scores would then go toward increasing the base principal pay, per the presentation. This is intended to stabilize principal pay while keeping the current structure of the plan in place, Lassiter said.

“Our current system ranks growth of all schools with no consideration of complexity or disadvantagement,” the presentation says. “This graph (below) shows the correlation between social economic status of the student population and the school鈥檚 ability to exceed growth.”

Screenshot from presentation on revisions to principal pay.

“This really proves that principals who serve more complex schools have unique challenges to overcome to accomplish similar results to schools located in more affluent areas across the state,” said Faulkenberry, the principal of in Craven County Schools.

Increasing principal retention

Nationally, 1 in 5 principals leave the profession each year, the presentation said. In North Carolina, that number is closer to 1 in 4.

“The problem of retention is greatest at high-poverty schools where nearly 30 percent of principals leave their school,” the presentation says. “As principals become more experienced, research shows they tend to move to lead schools with fewer complexity factors, schools that serve high-income areas with high-achieving students.”

Retention matters, as research shows that school principals greatly impact the schools they lead. According to , principals “contribute to important outcomes like student achievement, reduced absenteeism, and teacher retention.”

To help combat low principal retention, NCPAPA proposes adding the following retention pay bonuses:

  • $2,000 for 5-9 years as a principal.
  • $4,000 for 10-14 years as a principal.
  • $6,000 for 15+ years as a principal.

The proposed model also seeks to increase principal retention by establishing a complexity model that considers more than just school size. The lowest 鈥渃omplexity tier鈥 would start at $82,650 and the highest would start at $105,484.67.

鈥淢ore complex schools equals high stress, higher burnout, more turnover, and less stability for schools,鈥 Faulkenberry said. 鈥淪imply put, more complex schools are more difficult to lead.鈥

Here is a look at some of the factors the proposal would include:

Screenshot from presentation on revisions to principal pay.

Only 7% of N.C. principals agree or strongly agree that the current pay plan encourages high-performing principals to transition to low-performing schools, per the NCPAPA survey.

Accounting for factors beyond school size would encourage more principals to stay at high-poverty schools, Lassiter and Faulkenberry said.

They also spoke about the need to create a stronger “compensation progression” in North Carolina schools, citing a decreasing pool of candidates considering principalship. According to the NCPAPA survey, less than 15% of principals agree or strongly agree that the current pay plan encourages school leaders to transition into the role of the principal.

The principals’ proposal would address this problem, the presentation says, by “linking all school employees to one salary scale while ensuring that the principal is the highest paid employee in the building.” The proposed revisions start principal pay at the top teacher pay schedule, plus 25%.

“If we do not honor principal experience as part of the new proposal, we fear that the statistics will only become a greater concern across the state, further impacting our education future workforce,” Faulkenberry told lawmakers.

What did lawmakers say?

NCPAPA is asking state lawmakers to modify the principal pay plan in 2024 to “enhance recruitment, increase stability, add school complexity factors, and recognize experienced leadership.”

“It has never been more important to keep outstanding principals in their schools,” the presentation says.

, spoke about the importance of having school principals who are well known and have a strong reputation in the community.

, asked how the proposed plan would calculate complexity tiers.

“Each of these students would count for one point in each of these different complexity factors,” Faulkenberry said. “And then you would put all of those points into a bucket, and then that would tier those students in the pay plan.”

Warren also asked how much an impact shifting student enrollment has had on principal pay. He specifically mentioned an increase in homeschooling and families using Opportunity Scholarships to enroll their children in private school.

Faulkenberry and Lassiter said that impact is felt the strongest in smaller, transient districts. Faulkenberry clarified that school size is still considered a factor under the plan, but now one of many.

, said “bringing in more complexity factors is appropriate,” but questioned reducing incentives for growth in test scores.

“If our approach is to try to find the principles that are effective, it seems to me it just simply gives you higher pay for having a tough situation but doesn’t necessarily mean you’re effective in that role,” Blackwell said.

Committee Co-Chair , said the fiscal department will work to provide a “rough estimate” on how much the principals’ proposal would cost to implement.

, said lawmakers should continue discussing the principals’ proposal.

鈥淲e鈥檝e got to look at this,” said Biggs, who co-chairs the education reform committee. “Because a lot of principals that are in tough situations are superstars, but they鈥檙e not getting paid like they鈥檙e superstars because of the situation that they鈥檙e put in.鈥

The House Select Committee on Education Reform is scheduled to hold its final meeting of the short session on March 25. Torbett said the committee plans to issue their final report then.

This first appeared on and is republished here under a Creative Commons license.

]]>
Opinion: Want to Keep Teachers Happy? Build a Culture of Collaboration at School /article/want-to-keep-teachers-happy-build-a-culture-of-collaboration-at-school/ Tue, 12 Mar 2024 18:30:00 +0000 /?post_type=article&p=723708 In principal preparation programs, there is an often-used axiom: 鈥淚f you don鈥檛 feed the adults, they will eat the kids.鈥 It means that when staff are not growing or feeling respected, there are strongly correlated negative impacts on student learning and experience. I鈥檝e heard people criticize this idea as hyperbole, but it sticks because there is some truth to it. Teachers are hungry. They are hungry to be treated like professionals, and the best way to satiate this hunger is to build a culture of collaboration and shared decisionmaking. Placing key decisions closest to the people who will be asked to execute them treats educators as the expert professionals they are and will have a significantly positive impact on their school. To build this culture at your school, I recommend focusing on four key actions.

The first of these, modeling, is simple but surprisingly difficult to make habitual. School leaders run many meetings a week, but also have many more short, impromptu interactions with staff, and they must model the culture they want with during these brief interactions. When someone on your team comes with a question, model collaboration by first asking for their thoughts. When someone asks you to make a quick decision, respond by seeking their input on the best options. This sends the message over and over that you, as a leader, truly value the perspectives of your teaching team, which begins to build the ethos of collaboration and shared decisionmaking in your building.

After you have started reinforcing the values of this culture through modeling, you need to create structures for more formal and consistent shared decisionmaking. Start by choosing important aspects of your collective work, such as student culture, professional development or community events, and have your staff opt into and form mini-teams that align to their own interests. Once mini-teams are formed, you need a clear process for shared decisionmaking. I recommend using a simple, three-step process that can be repeated until a final decision has been made. First, several people from the mini-team create a proposal based on the group’s initial thoughts. Second, the proposal is presented to the entire group, debated and refined. Third, everyone has the opportunity to approve or disapprove of the proposal. At my school, anyone who gives a thumbs down is also volunteering to craft the next iteration of the proposal, which will then go through the same process. If your organization or team prefers majority rule when decisions are made, this process can be modified. The key is that there is a clear and accepted system for these groups to make decisions that is both efficient and aligns with your organizational and community values.


Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for 麻豆精品 Newsletter


Now that you have both an ethos of shared decisionmaking and the structures to support it, you need to ensure there is time dedicated to this work. This is a two-part commitment. First, you must set aside regular time for your mini-teams to meet. There are always constraints and competing needs, and you will need to work with a variety of stakeholders, including your staff, your district or charter management organization and any unions. The second part is a philosophical one. Working collaboratively and sharing decisionmaking simply takes longer than top-down decisionmaking. You get the time back in the efficiency of executing plans or decisions that everyone involved feels fully a part of, but the first part of the process is slower and requires patience and commitment from leaders to see it through. 

The final piece of building this culture on your team is to honestly and strategically share decisionmaking authority. Leaders have many decisions to make, ranging from minute to massive. If you believe in and have built a culture of collaboration and shared decisionmaking, you are going to be sharing at least some of that responsibility and privilege. You must do this honestly and strategically. You demonstrate honesty by never pretending to share decisionmaking when you already have a definitive perspective on what that decision needs to be. You will still want to make some decisions yourself. Own that and be transparent with your staff when that is the case. The strategy part comes from carefully choosing which decisions to share and which staff members to pass them on to. For example, I would never bring a decision about choosing a vendor for enrollment software to the teaching team, but I would to the operations team. I would definitely want input from the teaching team when adopting a curriculum for reading intervention, but the staff at a single school cannot make that decision because it would be difficult for a district or charter management organization to support different curricula at different sites. You also need to be mindful of decision fatigue. Being a teacher is extraordinarily demanding. Avoid overwhelming your staff further by ensuring that the decisions you are asking your team to share responsibility for are connected to their day-to-day work.

Creating a culture of collaboration and shared decisionmaking in your school will have incredible impacts in your community. Your team will feel more invested, more respected and more joyful in their work, and that will have a significant impact on the student experience and outcomes.

]]>
Artificial Intelligence & Schools: Innovators, Teachers Talk AI鈥檚 Impact at SXSW /article/18-ai-events-must-see-sxsw-edu-2024/ Thu, 15 Feb 2024 14:01:00 +0000 /?post_type=article&p=722328 returns to Austin, Texas, running March 3-7. As always, the event offers a wealth of panels, discussions, film screenings and workshops exploring emerging trends in education and innovation.

Keynote speakers this year include of Harlem Children鈥檚 Zone, of Stanford University, who popularized the idea of 鈥済rowth mindset,鈥 and actor , who starred on Broadway as George Washington in Hamilton. Jackson, who has a child on the autism spectrum, will discuss how doctors, parents and advocates are working together to change the ways neurodivergent kids communicate and learn.

But one issue that looms larger than most in the imaginations of educators is artificial intelligence. This year, South by Southwest EDU is offering dozens of sessions exploring AI鈥檚 potential and pitfalls. To help guide the way, we鈥檝e scoured the schedule to highlight 18 of the most significant presenters, topics and panels: 

Monday, March 4:

: The New School鈥檚 Maya Georgieva looks at how AI is ushering in a new era of immersive experiences. Her talk explores worlds that blur the lines between the virtual and real, where human ingenuity converges with intelligent machines. Georgieva will spotlight the next generation of creators shaping immersive realities, sharing emerging practices and projects from her students as well as her innovation labs and design jams. .

: Educators have long sought a better way to demonstrate learning, adapt instruction and build student confidence. Now, advancements in machine learning, natural language processing and data analytics are creating new possibilities for finding out what students know. This session will explore the ways in which AI is rendering assessments invisible, reducing stress and anxiety for students while improving objectivity and generating actionable insights for educators. .

: Many high-pressure professions pilots, doctors and professional athletes among others have access to high-quality simulators to help them learn and improve their skills. Could teachers benefit from hours in a simulator before setting foot in a classroom? In this session featuring presenters from the Relay Graduate School of Education and Wharton Interactive at the University of Pennsylvania, panelists will discuss virtual classrooms they鈥檙e piloting. They鈥檒l also address the challenges, successes and possibilities of developing an AI-driven teaching simulator. .

: In just the first half of 2023, venture capital investors poured more than $40 billion into AI startups. Yet big questions loom about how these technologies may impact education and the world of work. How are education and workforce investors separating wheat from chaff? Hear from a trio of venture capital and impact investors as they share the trends they鈥檙e watching. .

: This session will look at the profound transformations in teaching taking place in classrooms that blend AI with tailored, competency-focused education. Laura Jeanne Penrod of Southwest Career and Technical Academy and Nevada鈥檚 2024 will explore AI’s role in enhancing rather than supplanting quality teaching and what happens when schools embrace the human touch and educators鈥 emotional intelligence. .

Laura Jeanne Penrod

: In this interactive workshop led by women leaders from the University of Texas at Austin and the Waco (Texas) Independent School District, participants will learn how to design effective lesson plans and syllabi that incorporate AI tools such as ChatGPT and DALL-E to help prepare students to address society鈥檚 most pressing needs. .

: If we get AI in education right, it has the power to revolutionize how children learn. But if we get it wrong and fail to nourish children鈥檚 creativity their ability to innovate, think critically and problem solve we risk leaving them unprepared for a changing world. Creativity is the durable skill that AI cannot replace. And this panel, comprising educators and industry leaders, will explore the role we play in nurturing children鈥檚 innate creativity. .

: This panel, featuring early AI-in-education pioneers such as Amanda Bickerstaff, founder of AI for Education, Charles Foster, an AI researcher at Finetune Learning, and Ben Kornell,  co-founder of Edtech Insiders, will explore their journeys and what they consider the most exciting future opportunities and important challenges 鈥 in this emerging space. .

Tuesday, March 5:

: AI鈥檚 continued adoption in schools raises concerns about bias, especially toward students of color. This session, hosted by Common Sense Education鈥檚 Jamie Nunez, will highlight practical ways AI tools impact engagement for students from diverse racial and ethnic backgrounds. It will also address ethical concerns such as plagiarism and issues with facial recognition tools. And it will feature positive student experiences with AI and practical ways to ensure it remains inclusive. .

Jamie Nunez

: In 2024, what defines “AI literacy”? And how can we promote it effectively in schools? Marc Cicchino, innovation director for the Northern Valley Regional High School District in northeastern New Jersey, shares insights on fostering AI literacy through tailored learning experiences and initiatives like the NJ AI Literacy Summit. As part of the session, Cicchino guides attendees through organizing their own summit. . 

: Come watch a live recording of The Cusp, a new podcast hosted by Work Shift鈥檚 Paul Fain, exploring AI鈥檚 potential to not only enhance how we develop skills and improve job quality but exacerbate inequalities in our education and workforce systems. Leaders from Learning Collider, MDRC and Burning Glass Institute will share their perspectives on how AI can reach learners and workers in innovative ways, bridging the gap to economic opportunity. .

: While a few school districts have embraced artificial intelligence, neither the technology companies creating the AI nor the governments regulating it have provided guidance on how to integrate the new tech into classrooms. This has left districts wondering how to integrate AI safely, ethically and equitably. This panel of TeachAI.org founders and advisory members will discuss why government and education leaders must align standards with the needs of an increasingly AI-driven world. The panel features Khan Academy鈥檚 Kristen DiCerbo, Kara McWilliams of ETS, Code.org and ISTE鈥檚 Joseph South. .

Wednesday, March 6:

: Just as artificial intelligence is gaining momentum in education, the early childhood education workforce is experiencing record levels of burnout. A recent survey found many educators say they鈥檙e more likely to remain in their roles if they have access to better support, including high-quality classroom tools and flexible professional development. Could we harness AI to empower our early childhood workforce? This panel, led by the National Association for the Education of Young Children鈥檚 Stanford Accelerator for Learning, will explore the possibilities and challenges of AI in early childhood education. .

Perhaps no one in education needs to adapt more to AI than principals. This discussion with a principal and consultants from IDEO, The Leadership Academy and the Aspen Institute will explore how principals can lead during this time of swift change. Participants will come away with tangible suggestions for fostering innovation, adaptability and self-awareness. .

: This interactive session will give educators an opportunity to explore how they might use AI to advance their work, regardless of their background or technical expertise. 鈥婰ed by project managers and leadership development specialists with Teach For America, it will help participants create their own AI tools, build a deeper understanding of generative AI and develop a better sense of its promises and risks. .

Thursday, March 7: 

: This panel discussion, led by The Education Trust鈥檚 Dia Bryant and Khan Academy鈥檚 Kristen DiCerbo, will look at whether emerging uses of AI in schools could create a new digital divide. It will explore the intersection of AI and education equity and AI鈥檚 impact on students of color, as well as those from low-income backgrounds. The session will offer steps that educators and policymakers can take to ensure that schools factor in the culture and neurodiversity of students. . 

Kristen DiCerbo

: This session, led by Alex Tsado of Alliance4ai, will explore what鈥檚 required to engage diverse learners to become emerging AI leaders. It鈥檒l also explore how educators can help them build tech and leadership skills and promote an 鈥淎I-for-good鈥 worldview. And it鈥檒l examine the challenges that Black communities face in AI development 鈥 and propose research and solutions that can be scaled easily. .

: This panel brings together of the U.S. Department of Education鈥檚 Office of Educational Technology and Jeremy of Digital Promise for an interactive conversation about generative AI that will integrate two distinctive and powerful vantage points 鈥 policy and research. They鈥檒l reflect on the listening sessions they鈥檝e conducted, talk about policy and share insights from major research initiatives that address the efficacy, equity and ethics of generative AI. .

]]>
Virginia Launches Pilot to Mentor New Principals /article/virginia-launches-pilot-to-mentor-new-principals/ Tue, 26 Dec 2023 16:01:00 +0000 /?post_type=article&p=718536 This article was originally published in

The Virginia Department of Education is launching a pilot program to help support new and inexperienced principals at federally designated at-risk schools in an effort to address what officials call a 鈥渃rucial need.鈥

鈥淲e are excited about it. Mentoring principals has been a long time coming to the commonwealth,鈥 said Randy Barrack, CEO of the Virginia Association of Secondary School Principals, which along with the Virginia Association of Elementary School Principals is partnering with VDOE, in an email to the Mercury.

Nationally, 80% of all public school principals remained at the same school in 2020-21 where they had been the year prior, according to data. The remaining 20% moved to a different school or left the principal role altogether.


Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for 麻豆精品 Newsletter


In Virginia, according to , Fairfax County has lost dozens of principals since the COVID-19 pandemic. Those who spoke with the news station cited pandemic-related burnout and growing pressures to overcome learning loss as reasons for leaving the profession. Some also said their departures were due to a disconnect with and lack of transparency from administrative offices.

Virginia鈥檚 principal vacancy rate is less than 2% for each of the three school levels 鈥 elementary, middle and secondary, according to VDOE data from 2021 to 2023.

Under , new principals serve a three-year probationary period before acquiring continuing contract status.

Krista Arnold, executive director of the Virginia Association of Elementary School Principals, said many principals accept leadership positions with limited years of experience because of the growing national shortage of educators. Mentors, she said, will be able to provide management and instructional tips.

鈥淭his is going to give new principals a highly skilled, experienced veteran who鈥檚 not within their division, who is a safe person for them to talk to, who could be a sounding board because the principalship is really lonely and can be isolating,鈥 said Arnold, who spent 20 years as an elementary school principal.

Besides shaping instruction, Arnold said principals have a significant influence on student achievement, attendance, teacher retention and community involvement.

Virginia鈥檚 new mentorship program, she said, will hopefully end the outdated notion that principals should be left to 鈥渟ink or swim鈥 and instead offer essential aid and support, 鈥減roviding a partner in what too often can often be an isolating role.鈥

The program鈥檚 focus on principals in at-risk schools, whose populations include students from low-income families with a higher than average probability of dropping out or failing school, will also help improve teacher performance and student learning, Barrack and Arnold said in a joint statement with the Department of Education.

The pilot program is expected to be rolled out before the start of the next school year.

鈥淧rincipals are the leaders in their school buildings. They set the tone and are the ones looked to establish a vision for high standards and success,鈥 said Superintendent of Public Instruction Lisa Coons in a statement. 鈥淔or many new principals, it can be tough, on-the-job training. With this mentoring pilot project, we are focusing on supporting our new principals leading in some of our most challenged schools and equipping them with support that can help them and their schools be successful.鈥

is part of States Newsroom, a network of news bureaus supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Virginia Mercury maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Sarah Vogelsong for questions: info@virginiamercury.com. Follow Virginia Mercury on and .

]]>
Alaska Program Aimed at Keeping School Principals to Triple in Size /article/alaska-program-aimed-at-keeping-school-principals-to-triple-in-size/ Wed, 11 Oct 2023 17:01:00 +0000 /?post_type=article&p=716086 This article was originally published in

A program aimed at supporting and retaining Alaska principals will more than triple its participation this year, coordinators told the state鈥檚 Board of Education at its October 5th meeting. The state鈥檚 two largest districts will join the Alaska School Leadership Academy, increasing its ranks from 36 to 118 principals.

Lisa Parady, executive director of the Alaska Council of School Administrators, helped revive the program in 2018 with former Department of Education and Early Development Commissioner Michael Johnson.

鈥淲e鈥檙e here to share the good news that it鈥檚 working,鈥 she said.


Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for 麻豆精品 Newsletter


Parady said Alaska鈥檚 principal turnover rate statewide was around 38% when the program started. Now, her data shows the turnover rate is below 25%.

Jennifer Rinaldi, the principal lead for the program, said strong principals have a stabilizing effect on the whole school and can increase teacher retention.

鈥淥ur overarching goal for the ASLA program is really increased stability within our schools in our communities,鈥 she said. 鈥淲e want positive teacher retention in our buildings, and we know that鈥檚 going to lead to student achievement.鈥

Rinaldi said the principals they mentor ask for more support with four main areas: family engagement, staff supervision, recognizing and resolving issues effectively, and public advocacy.

鈥淥ur goal is to support their instructional focus by providing professional development in these areas and really enhancing that institutional leadership,鈥 she said.

The program is a state-grant-funded partnership between the Education Department and the Alaska Council of School Administrators. It is a two-year program that matches school principals with mentors.

The number of mentors is growing also. Last year, 25 veteran educators participated; this year, the program will have 61 mentors. The program鈥檚 data shows that more than 70% of principals that sign up for the program complete it.

Sam Jordan, the grant director, said the program is foundational to the success of the state鈥檚 public school system.

鈥淏y focusing our efforts on the support of early career principals, we are rightly investing in the people who serve as linchpins in schools around our state,鈥 he said. 鈥淧rincipals set the school climate and the instructional culture in each school by building their effectiveness and competence as leaders and promoting their retention over longer periods of time.鈥

He said that strengthens the stability of the entire public school system and allows schools to focus more resources on student achievement.

The board and DEED Commissioner Deena Bishop asked to see data that shows the correlation between student achievement and principal retention. Dale Cope, the program鈥檚 evaluator, said that the group would like to track that, but since school testing has changed the program is waiting for more more data to track that correlation.

鈥淲e want to move in that direction. We need to, in order to show that success. We know it鈥檚 working, but now we need to show those student outcomes that really support that,鈥 Parady said.

Parady said that the program is effective, but the need for increased principal and teacher retention is still great.

鈥淲e鈥檙e still experiencing incredible turnover,鈥 she said.

is part of States Newsroom, a network of news bureaus supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Alaska Beacon maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Andrew Kitchenman for questions: info@alaskabeacon.com. Follow Alaska Beacon on and .

]]>
New North Carolina Program Aims to Support Development of High-Quality Principals /article/new-north-carolina-program-aims-to-support-development-of-high-quality-principals/ Wed, 04 Oct 2023 17:01:00 +0000 /?post_type=article&p=715754 This article was originally published in

State Superintendent of Public Instruction Catherine Truitt likes to talk about principals as a policy lever. Most policy reforms center on teachers and instruction — but school building leadership, she says while referencing a Wallace Foundation report, is effective because it touches both.

But using principal leadership as a lever for downstream change has been hard amid elevated stress, burnout, and a leaky pipeline of qualified candidates in some parts of the state. That doesn鈥檛 mean great leaders aren鈥檛 out there, state leaders say, or that North Carolina can鈥檛 invest in growing great leaders statewide.

That鈥檚 why more than 200 new principals gathered in a conference space last week for the first meeting of the Early Career Principals Academy, a professional learning program intended to grow the leadership skills of principals in their first three years on the job.


Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for 麻豆精品 Newsletter


鈥淵ou all are the spark in your school,鈥 Truitt told the gathering. 鈥淔or those of you who are new, it’s gonna be hard. But I promise you it is well worth it. You are changing lives.鈥

This inaugural cohort of the ECPA will help design the program, which is just the latest in a line of partnerships between the education system and principal associations.

A continuum of support for principal leadership development

The spark that flared into the ECPA was lit at a meeting of the State Board of Education. Actually, it鈥檚 helpful to begin before that.

In 2015, the state established the Transforming Principal Preparation program (TP3). It was intended to create more and better principals at a time when there weren鈥檛 enough strong candidates to fill the needs. That initiative, now called the Principal Fellows program, took teachers with leadership aspirations and gave them professional development and tools to enter assistant principalships.

The idea was to create a pipeline for future principals.

About 200 members were inducted in the first cohort, but fewer than 30 made it to the principalship.

鈥淭hey were languishing in those (AP) roles and not getting promoted,鈥 said Shirley Prince, executive director of the North Carolina Principals and Assistant Principals’ Association (NCPAPA). 鈥淪o we wanted something to identify the bright stars and get them ready to step into that principal鈥檚 role.鈥

In response, the Department of Public Instruction (DPI) partnered with NCPAPA last year to establish the AP Accelerator. That program offers professional development and coaching to select assistant principals, nominated by their superintendents, to help them enhance their skills and become principals.

The 2022 State Principal of the Year, Patrick Greene, leads the inaugural ECPA cohort through discussion topics and activities. (Rupen Fofaria/EducationNC)

Truitt and her team at DPI updated the State Board of Education on the AP Accelerator last fall. At the time, there wasn鈥檛 much state professional development programming for new principals. The Fellows program and NCPAPA鈥檚 Future Ready program focused on the assistant principalship, and NCPAPA鈥檚 Distinguished Leadership in Practice (DLP) program was designed for more veteran principals.

State Board Vice Chair Alan Duncan wondered whether the AP Accelerator 鈥 a one-year program with ongoing coaching 鈥 was enough. Prince鈥檚 eyes lit up, and she began scribbling ideas for what became the ECPA.

鈥淭his was the missing piece,鈥 she said.

Supporting new principals

The ECPA was created through a partnership among DPI, NCPAPA, the N.C. Alliance for School Leadership Development, and the Belk Foundation. The ECPA curriculum will align with North Carolina and national principal performance standards and competencies while also fostering a network culture.

It is designed to meet the needs of school leaders in a blended format of in-person and virtual meetings, all facilitated by school leaders identified as exemplary.

From the show of hands during Prince鈥檚 welcome at the ECPA鈥檚 inaugural meeting, more than half of the principals in the program this year are in their first year.

鈥淲e know that the principalship, particularly in high-needs schools, is a challenging role,鈥 said Tabari Wallace, the 2018 Principal of the Year and Truitt鈥檚 principals advisor. 鈥淎nd this three-year, statewide leadership development program will provide early-career principals with the support they need to improve their effectiveness, retention and satisfaction while boosting student achievement.鈥

The in-person sessions are designed to motivate and inspire participants and help them focus on conditions they can control to achieve optimum school environments. Follow-up, virtual sessions will provide a curriculum designed to build the leadership skills and competencies necessary to effectively control the conditions required for student success.

In the third year of the program, participants will complete NCPAPA’s DLP program.

鈥淏y investing in principals through programs like the Early Career Principals Academy, we invest in the culture and community of a school that impacts the next generation of students across our state,鈥 Truitt said. 鈥淲e know the critical role principals take in creating an environment of learning and growing for all in their buildings. Through the ECPA, principals are provided with the tools and resources to help them succeed and thrive in their roles as school leaders.鈥

This first appeared on and is republished here under a Creative Commons license.

]]>
Before Trump, D.A. Fani Willis Targeted Teachers in Atlanta Cheating Scandal /article/before-trump-d-a-fani-willis-targeted-teachers-in-atlanta-cheating-scandal/ Fri, 18 Aug 2023 11:30:00 +0000 /?post_type=article&p=713554 A decade before she unleashed the sprawling case now entangling former President Donald Trump in Georgia, Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis used similar methods to target an unlikely group: public school educators in Atlanta.

As an assistant district attorney in 2013, Willis turned heads in one of her first big cases: She helped convene a grand jury that indicted decorated Superintendent Beverly Hall and nearly three dozen other educators for cheating on state standardized tests. In the end, Willis brought a dozen cases to trial, with a jury convicting 11.

This week, Willis invoked the same statute 鈥 Georgia鈥檚 Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations, or RICO, Act 鈥 to indict Trump and 18 others in an alleged plot to overturn the state鈥檚 2020 election results. 

In doing so, she offered a reminder of her role in a divisive chapter in the city鈥檚 recent history. While the former president that Willis is, among other things, 鈥渁 rabid partisan,鈥 the cheating prosecutions left fissures in her own community, where many say she stood up for children but others accuse her of turning her back on Black educators. 

鈥楥ooking the books鈥

Hall, the Atlanta superintendent, arrived in the district in 1999, eventually leading what she would call a data-driven turnaround. She told observers that under her tenure, Atlanta schools were 鈥渄ebunking the American algorithm that socio-economics predicts academic success,鈥 The Atlanta Journal-Constitution .

By 2009, her efforts had earned her one of education鈥檚 top honors: . But the same year, the Journal-Constitution the first of several stories analyzing Atlanta鈥檚 results on the Georgia Criterion-Referenced Competency Test. The analysis found that scores had risen at rates that were statistically 鈥渁ll but impossible.鈥 It also found that district officials disregarded internal irregularities and retaliated against whistleblowers. 

Critics would soon compare Hall to 鈥渁 Mafia boss who demanded fealty from subordinates while perpetrating a massive, self-serving fraud,鈥 the city newspaper reported at the time. Willis pursued Hall using the same tools many prosecutors employ against Mafia bosses and drug kingpins. In bringing charges under the state鈥檚 RICO Act, Willis alleged that Hall and her colleagues used the 鈥渓egitimate enterprise鈥 of the school system to carry out an illegitimate act: cheating.

Lonnie King, a former head of the local NAACP, the newspaper that when he looked at the data, 鈥淚 thought Beverly Hall was cooking the books鈥 as early as 2006.

The newspaper鈥檚 coverage led Gov. Sonny Perdue to appoint a team of special investigators, who conducted 2,100 interviews and reviewed 800,000 documents. By 2011, they uncovered cheating in 44 of the 56 schools they examined, concluding that 178 educators participated. Investigators eventually found widespread tampering with test papers and concluded that Hall stood at the center of 鈥渁 culture of corruption.鈥

Special investigator Michael Bowers, a former state attorney general, in 2013 that interrogating teachers in the scheme had left him in tears.

“The thing I remember most was talking to some of the teachers who had been mistreated, mostly single moms,鈥 he said. 鈥淎nd it’s heartbreaking. They told of how they had been forced to cheat.鈥 One told him, 鈥淚 had no choice.鈥

鈥極n the backs of babies鈥

Hall retired in 2011, but on March 29, 2013, a Fulton County grand jury indicted her and more than 30 others in what Willis called a conspiracy comprising administrators, principals, teachers and even a school secretary.

Similar to this week鈥檚 indictments, the Atlanta defendants faced charges of racketeering, conspiracy and making false statements. Hall also faced theft charges because her rising salary was tied to test scores 鈥 in 2009, the year she was named Superintendent of the Year, she got , prosecutors noted.

Former Atlanta Mayor Andrew Young, who in 2014 asked the judge in Superintendent Beverly Hall鈥檚 criminal trial to be 鈥渕erciful鈥 and drop the case. Hall died of breast cancer in 2015. (Monica Morgan/Getty Images)

If convicted, Hall could have served as many as 45 years in prison, but she soon fell ill and the judge in the case indefinitely postponed her trial. At an April 2014 hearing, Andrew Young, a former Atlanta mayor and United Nations ambassador, rose in the courtroom and asked the judge to be 鈥渕erciful鈥 and drop the case against her.

鈥淟et God judge her,鈥 he said.

Hall died of breast cancer in 2015, at age 68.

Public opinion on the case was sharply divided, with many Black commentators accusing Willis of overreach. But eventually, 34 of Hall鈥檚 subordinates faced criminal charges.

Brittney Cooper

Brittney Cooper, a professor of Women’s and Gender Studies and Africana Studies at Rutgers University, : 鈥淪capegoating Black teachers for failing in a system that is designed for Black children, in particular, not to succeed is the real corruption here.鈥

Cooper noted that former Washington, D.C., Schools Chancellor Michelle Rhee, who is Korean-American, had also been for creating a 鈥渃ulture of fear about test scores.鈥 An by USA Today revealed findings similar to Atlanta鈥檚, but an inspector general report found of widespread cheating and Rhee never faced prosecution.

While most of the Atlanta educators eventually pleaded guilty to avoid jail time, 12 went to trial in 2014. As with the Trump case, this one was complex: Jury selection took more than , and jurors sat through complex statistical analyses of answer-sheet erasure patterns, among other matters. At a few points in the trial, a dozen or more lawyers offered different versions of events.

A demonstrator holds a sign in support of prosecutor Fani Willis outside of the Lewis R. Slaton Courthouse before this week鈥檚 indictment of former U.S. President Donald Trump in Atlanta, Georgia. (Christian Monterrosa/AFP)

In an early case that went to trial in 2013, Willis said supervisor Tamara Cotman worked to protect educators鈥 jobs by advising principals under investigation not to cooperate with state investigators 鈥 a charge Cotman denied 鈥 and by vowing to return high test scores at any cost.

鈥淪he did it on the backs of babies,鈥 Willis during closing arguments. The jury acquitted Cotman, who was later convicted of other charges in the larger case.

Former President Donald Trump at the Georgia state GOP convention on June 10, 2023. Fani Willis, the prosecutor who is pursuing the Georgia election case, made a name for herself a decade ago by pursuing similar racketeering charges against Atlanta educators. (Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images)

In court, Willis told the jury of 鈥渃heating parties鈥 at which educators got together to erase children鈥檚 incorrect answers on test sheets and pencil in correct ones. At a few of the parties, she said, educators 鈥渁te fish and grits 鈥 I can鈥檛 make this up.鈥 

The jury convicted 11 of the 12 of racketeering and other charges.

The Rev. Dr. Raphael G. Warnock, at the time senior pastor of Ebenezer Baptist Church 鈥 he now serves as a U.S. Senator 鈥 The New York Times, 鈥淭here鈥檚 no question that this has not been our finest hour. It鈥檚 a dark chapter, but it鈥檚 just that. It鈥檚 a chapter.鈥

In 2015, commentators Van Jones and Mark Holden that the educators convicted in the case were 鈥渢he latest victims of overcriminalization,鈥 facing serious jail time because of Willis鈥檚 鈥渦nprecedented use鈥 of RICO. Three were sentenced to seven years in prison, they noted, while others received one- or two-year sentences if they didn鈥檛 accept plea deals. 

鈥淭hese punishments do not fit the crimes,鈥 they wrote. 

Sen. Raphael G. Warnock, then senior pastor of the Ebenezer Baptist Church, called the cheating scandal a “dark chapter.” (Curtis Compton/Getty Images)

Since then, several of the defendants have loudly proclaimed their innocence, even as they鈥檝e served prison time or pursued appeals to avoid it. A handful of those cases remain outstanding. In several instances, they and their defenders say they’ve spent their life savings pursuing appeals.

In 2019, Shani Robinson, one of those found guilty, about the ordeal. In an interview, , 鈥渢he thought of being blamed for something that I did not do is horrifying. … I felt like if I was on the right side of justice, that one day I would be vindicated. That was the moment that I decided that I would never take a plea deal.”

But many parents saw it differently.

Shawnna Hayes-Jocelyn had three of her four children in classes at schools affected by the cheating. She said Willis rightly brought RICO charges. 

鈥淵ou鈥檇 better believe she did the right thing, because that was the worst Black-on-Black crime example that could have ever happened around education,鈥 she told 麻豆精品. 鈥淏ecause what they did to those children is that they didn’t give those children options and opportunities.鈥

Shawnna Hayes-Jocelyn

Hayes-Jocelyn said her mind was made up once she read the state report that alleged widespread cheating among educators. 

鈥淲hen I read that report and saw what was happening in that school system, yeah, people said, 鈥極h, this is RICO. We think about RICO as organized crime.鈥 I said, 鈥楾his was organized crime.鈥欌 

Those familiar with Willis鈥檚 work say she鈥檚 tenacious. Atlanta NAACP president Gerald Griggs, one of the defense attorneys in the cheating trial, told The Guardian this week that Trump is 鈥済oing to be very surprised when he鈥檚 sitting across from her for months on trial. He鈥檒l find out how great of a lawyer she really is.鈥

Asked in 2021 if she had regrets about pursuing the school cheating cases, Willis was blunt, the Times that by going after teachers, principals and administrators, she was 鈥渄efending poor Black children.” Public education, she said, offers these children their only chance to get ahead. 鈥淪o if what I am being criticized for is doing something to protect people that did not have a voice for themselves, I sit in that criticism, and y鈥檃ll can put it in my obituary.鈥

]]>
Principals are Leaving Their Jobs at an Accelerating Rate in Pennsylvania /article/principals-are-leaving-their-jobs-at-an-accelerating-rate-in-pennsylvania/ Fri, 14 Jul 2023 11:30:00 +0000 /?post_type=article&p=711416 This article was originally published in

A new report by Penn State鈥檚 Center for Education Evaluation and Policy Analysis shows that nearly 15.4% of principals left Pennsylvania schools between 2021-2022 and 2022-2023. The 4.2% increase is the highest since accurate employment records have been kept.

Out of the 463 educators who left the principalship in 2022-2023, 250 educators became employed in another position with the Pennsylvania public education system.

Nearly one-third of educators found employment in managerial and leadership positions and more than 21% entered district administration. Another 18% left the principalship for an assistant principal position and more than 15% returned to teaching.


Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for 麻豆精品 Newsletter


鈥淭he pandemic played a huge role in principal turnover in Pennsylvania,鈥 said Ed Fuller, education professor at Penn State University and author of the report.

鈥淧rincipals had to flip overnight from in-person to virtual learning and many of them didn鈥檛 have the knowledge and skills to do that,鈥 he said. 鈥淭hey worked long hours while also leading the school, staff, students and their families. It was a lot for one person to take on all at once.

鈥淎lso, many of the folks who quit the principalship moved into central office positions,鈥 he added. 鈥淭he pay is better for a lot of these positions and the pressure is lower.鈥

In the report, Pennsylvania schools with more than 93.7% students of color had an average principal attrition rate of 23.1%. Schools with less than 5% of students of color had an average principal attrition rate of 11.8%.

The principal turnover rate was also high in the Commonwealth鈥檚 poorest school systems at 14.2% compared to 12.7% for principals in the wealthiest districts.

Nearly 32.8% of charter school principals left the principalship in 2022-2023 compared to 13.2% of traditional district school principals.

High school principals were the most likely to leave with a 16.9% attrition rate, followed by middle school principals at 13.8% and elementary school principals at 12.5%.

Black female principals had the greatest attrition rate in Pennsylvania at 19%, meaning nearly one out of every five Black female principals left the principalship from 2022 to 2023.

Black males had the second highest attrition rate at 17.4% followed by Hispanic females at 16.7%. The lowest attrition rate was for Hispanic males at 12%, according to the report.

鈥淢ost principals do not last at the same school for more than four years,鈥 Fuller said. 鈥淔or a lot of high schools, when students come in as a freshman, they鈥檒l have a different principal when they graduate in four years.

鈥淔or most kids coming into kindergarten, they鈥檒l have a different elementary principal when they finish elementary school,鈥 he said. 鈥淚t has a negative effect on teachers and students because there is no continuity in schools.

鈥淩esearch has also shown that Black students in Pennsylvania schools succeed when they also have Black principals and teachers who stay longer,鈥 he added.

Among the suggestions Fuller offered to address principal attrition includes: an increase in principal salaries, provide stipends for principals at hard-to-staff schools and adopt and implement a statewide principal working condition survey.

鈥淥ne thing that will help with principal attrition is an increase in pay, but it also depends on how much they like their job and the working conditions of their job,鈥 Fuller said. 鈥淪upport from the superintendent and the central office will also increase longevity.

鈥淚f they鈥檙e providing principals with support, mentoring and helping them make decisions they will stay longer,鈥 he said. 鈥淣obody can no longer work over 60 to 80 hours a week for multiple years in a row.

鈥淚t鈥檚 just not sustainable, so providing more help to principals is also important,鈥 he added. 鈥淒oes a school have assistant principals and teacher leaders who can help the principals at the schools? Offering more pay and providing more support to principals can definitely help address principal attrition in the long run.鈥

is part of States Newsroom, a network of news bureaus supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Pennsylvania Capital-Star maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor John Micek for questions: info@penncapital-star.com. Follow Pennsylvania Capital-Star on and .

]]>
To Prevent Principal Exodus, New Partnerships Offer $20K Stipends, Therapy /article/to-prevent-principal-exodus-new-partnerships-offer-20k-stipends-therapy/ Thu, 28 Jul 2022 11:15:00 +0000 /?post_type=article&p=692494 Free therapy and professional coaching. $20,000 stipends. 

These are some of the incentives and supports aimed at preventing an exodus of principals and school administrators taking on pandemic stressors and the nation鈥檚 divisive climate. 

Focused on problem solving, self-care and leadership skills, a handful of nonprofits run by experienced educators have launched support and training programs to aid principals, particularly leaders of color who are underrepresented in the field and experiencing more than their peers. 


Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for 麻豆精品 Newsletter


Organizations are also recognizing a window of opportunity: recruiting and retaining principals of color to better match and support an increasingly diverse student population. Roughly of U.S. public school students are Indigenous, Black, Hispanic/Latino, Asian or multiracial, while about . 

鈥溾楬ow could this be done differently? How can we support you?鈥 We’re not hearing that conversation. It is 鈥榶es you did this, now do this on top of what you’re doing.鈥 And I think that is driving a lot of people out because you don’t feel like you can be human,鈥 said TaraShaun Cain, executive director of the Black Principals Network. 

The group is one of several support networks that launched during the pandemic, as many leaders 鈥 faced with hostility from parents, death within their family, health concerns and working alongside mental health challenges 鈥 have said they may .

One new training is taking aim at the underlying cause of stress educators witness in tapped-out peers: The current role of principal has become unsustainable. And if reimagining school structures isn鈥檛 a part of training for the next generation of principals, school systems will likely continue to fail and overtax leaders.

Recognizing the emotional toll of leading schools in the current climate, the partnered with BetterHelp, an online mental health service platform, to provide leaders free phone, text or video counseling.聽

Several are extending support beyond seated principals. Recruiting the next generation of school leaders is becoming more urgent, as one New York teacher leader noticed. 

鈥淭here’s a lot more hesitancy,鈥 said Margarita Lopez, a teacher and instructional coach for other educators at Urban Assembly Maker, a career and technical school in New York City. 

Lopez, who does not know anyone else currently interested in leadership, is pursuing the shift to leadership out of frustration, eager to change current systems that have left teachers unsupported, without meaningful feedback or professional development. 

鈥淚 saw it as a call to action for myself鈥’ve seen a lot of people that I’ve taught with leave education altogether,鈥 Lopez said. 鈥淚’m seeing more of that, than people wanting to stay in education and become a school leader.鈥

To make the role more attractive, at least one program is baking in opportunities to reshape school design while bearing the cost of training to make the career accessible and enticing to a more diverse pool of applicants.

Launched by Springpoint, a nonprofit dedicated to reimagining high school, and Boston-based philanthropy The Barr Foundation, the Transformative Leaders Massachusetts program is recruiting to better reflect the state鈥檚 diverse student population. 

For example, they may look to recruit multilingual leaders to support the state鈥檚 immigrant families, particularly from Brazil, Cape Verde the Azores and mainland Portugal. Massachusetts has the in the country.

The tuition-free leadership program will include coaching on how to encourage staff and student identity development, competency-based learning, and managing teams 鈥 thinking through the system and volume of direct reports that principals manage daily, for example.

About 10 teachers will begin the pilot two-year development program this summer 鈥 each participant will earn $20,000 stipends on top of their existing school salaries.

鈥淭here has been an addition of work without compensation. And for us, this is really a statement of valuing their time鈥 this should not be something that educators go into debt for. This should be something that is a pathway that feels clear and open,鈥 said Lauren Bassi, director of leadership and school design at Springpoint and former English teacher.

Breaking down the financial barrier for leaders to enter the profession while creating support has also been a priority for the , child of the popular leadership training program New Leaders, Clark Atlanta University and Morehouse College. 

New principal fellows can complete a certificate-only program for $10,000, or earn a Master鈥檚 simultaneously for $20,000, and receive support to apply for grant funding. Fellows can pursue licensed positions in 37 states and Washington, D.C., thanks to recent state approvals, and will ultimately join a New Leaders alumni network of over 8,000. 

鈥淲hen we talk about fundamentally changing what is happening in education in our country, this is what we mean: transforming the system so that every school is led by an equity-focused principal with the highest expectations for every child,鈥 J. Fidel Turner, Dean of the Clark Atlanta School of Education, said in a press release.

New Leaders鈥檚 latest fellowship will focus on building the pipeline of principals of color to better reflect and serve student populations. Principals of color create better academic outcomes for students of color 鈥 who make up the nationally 鈥 and are more effective than their peers at recruiting and retaining teachers of color, according to .

The next few years could present an opportunity to better diversify the field and encourage better outcomes for students of color, , said New Leaders CEO Jean Desravines.

鈥淲e are not saying that we should transition out existing white principals. What we’re saying is there’s a recognition that there will be significant turnover in the field, a mass exodus because of mental health issues, because of COVID, because of the political environment,鈥 Desravines told 麻豆精品. 鈥淚t will be a missed opportunity if we are not being intentional and strategic about how we build the pipeline in a way that ensures there’s far greater representation than there’s been in the past.鈥 

Desravines added that principals, particularly those without supportive district leadership, have been feeling 鈥渋ncredibly lonely.鈥 There are about 11 and 9% of Black and Latino principals nationally, respectively. Some may be the only leader of color in their district or county 鈥 experiencing a mix of racist hostility or taking on more emotional labor to support marginalized students than their peers. 

Black Principal Network鈥檚 Executive Director Cain, for instance, built her career in her hometown of Chicago alongside many Black educators and leaders. But she knows that some, in places like Madison, Wisconsin, are the only ones in their district or county fiercely advocating for the 鈥渂abies that look like me.鈥 

It鈥檚 become necessary to share strategies across state lines, so that leaders who would previously have never crossed paths, can share lessons learned like how to advance an equity initiative or deal with a combative school board. 

鈥淭here’s [professional] development needed, but what I learned is there are some internal obstacles that our guys face, too,鈥 said Keith Brooks, founder of the National Fellowship for Black and Latino Male Educators, the group offering free access to BetterHelp therapy. 鈥淚mposter syndrome 鈥 just understanding their worth or value, or internalized racism, and being able to show up as their authentic self鈥 that was one of the biggest things that was getting in our guys鈥 ways.鈥 

The Black Principal鈥檚 Network recognized a similar need near the beginning of the pandemic and widespread protests against racism and police violence. What began as a Facebook group has morphed into an online community of over 350; principals participate in self-care, sustainability, and self-discovery programming. 

While the Fellowship and Network specifically advocate for principals of color, the strategies and support offer a roadmap for the broader population of leaders. 

鈥淪ometimes you feel like being vulnerable or taking time means that you are abandoning, or it is a sign of weakness鈥e have to change that narrative,鈥 Cain said. 鈥淲e have to create a space where our leaders can actually get refilled and be recharged beyond what we have right now.鈥

]]>
7 Things We Learned About COVID鈥檚 Impact on Education From Survey of 800 Schools /article/7-things-we-learned-about-covids-impact-on-education-from-survey-of-800-schools/ Tue, 19 Jul 2022 21:01:00 +0000 /?post_type=article&p=693129 The pandemic years have taken a dramatic toll on the nation’s public schools, according to , affecting staffing, students鈥 behavior, attendance, nutrition, and mental health.

鈥淭here was a lot of disruption in actually providing quality instruction to students whether it is access to a teacher, a live teacher, or the mode of learning was chaotic and vacillating, and it ,鈥 said Commissioner Peggy Carr of the National Center for Education Statistics, an arm of the institute. 鈥淭his is an important way to understand the impact of the pandemic on our country.鈥 


Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for 麻豆精品 Newsletter


The School Pulse Panel is a series of surveys from January 2022 through May 2022 measuring COVID-19鈥檚 impact on public education. The surveys were sent to 800-850 public schools, with principals, administrators, superintendents, and staff responding. Here are some takeaways from IES鈥檚 School Pulse Panel:

1. COVID-19 negatively affected student鈥檚 development

A May 2022 survey found more than 80% of public schools reported 鈥渟tunted behavioral and socioemotional development鈥 in their students because of the COVID-19 pandemic,鈥 a 56% increase in 鈥渃lassroom disruptions from student misconduct,鈥 and a 49% increase in 鈥渞owdiness outside of the classroom.鈥 All schools surveyed reported a 55% increase in 鈥渟tudent tardiness.鈥 The use of cell phones, computers, or other electronics when not permitted for all schools increased by 42%.

2. Chronic teacher and student absenteeism has increased

Student and teacher absenteeism in the 2021-2022 school year increased in comparison to school years before the COVID-19 pandemic. In the 2021-2022 school year 61% of public schools also reported聽it is 鈥渕uch more difficult鈥 to find substitute teachers; and that

  • 74% reported having 鈥渁dministrators cover classes.鈥 
  • 71% reported having 鈥渘on-teaching staff cover classes.鈥 
  • 68% reported having 鈥渙ther teachers cover classes during their prep periods.鈥
  • 51% reported 鈥渟eparate sections and classes鈥 combined into one room.鈥

Carr said she had heard from colleagues in Boston and Florida school districts that because of staffing shortages, superintendents had to return to classrooms to teach 鈥渂ecause it was so bad. I had heard that, but to see it in a nationally representative sample of schools that prevalent, is sobering.鈥

Carr also said COVID quarantines are a factor in student absenteeism. 鈥淚t is normal to have students out because of quarantine, so when we talk about student absenteeism, it鈥檚 not all just because a student is just out, sometimes it is that they鈥檝e been quarantined because of COVID,鈥 she said. 鈥淭hat鈥檚 part of the new normal.鈥

3. There is a greater need for mental health services among students and staff.

70% of public schools reported that 鈥渢he percentage of students who have sought mental health services increased since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic;鈥 and that 34% of public school students seeking out mental health services more than others were 鈥渆conomically disadvantaged students.鈥 The second highest percentage (25%) of public schools who sought out mental health services more than others were special needs students (25%).

鈥淭he teachers are having a rough time鈥oo, is what these data are showing,鈥 Carr said. 29% of public schools reported that the 鈥渄egree to which staff have sought mental health services from the school since the start of COVID-19鈥 has increased. 鈥淭hey are overworked, they don’t have the staff there to help them, teachers are quitting. They are having to teach courses they have not taught before. All of these things culminate into an unhealthy work environment for the teachers,鈥 she said.

4. Public schools face barriers to getting students the mental health services they need.

Most public schools (61%) said a limitation was 鈥渋nsufficient mental health professional staff coverage to manage caseload,鈥 57% of the schools said it was 鈥渋nadequate access to licensed mental health professionals,鈥 and 48% said 鈥渋nadequate funding.鈥

鈥淎 licensed professional is expensive,鈥 Carr said. 鈥淭oo few professionals are available in these schools to actually provide those services and inadequate access to licensed professionals that can really provide the level of quality of services that they need.鈥

5. Schools changed their calendars to support students and staff

Nearly one third of the schools 鈥 28% 鈥 surveyed reported making changes to their 鈥渄aily or yearly academic calendar to mitigate potential mental health issues for students and staff.鈥 In early July, went into effect to make high school and middle classes start no earlier than 8:30am. , New York, and Massachusetts lawmakers have had similar discussions about making school start times later.

6. Most schools are in-person 

By May 2022, most schools 鈥 99% 鈥 were offering full-time in-person instruction, a slight increase from January when it was 97%, the survey found. In January, 40% of all public schools also offered a full-time remote option, which decreased to 34% in February, 33% in March, April, and May, the survey found.

7. School Breakfast and Meal Programs faced challenges.

Nearly 40% of the schools that operate USDA school and breakfast meal programs, 鈥渞eported challenges obtaining enough food, beverages, and/or meal service supplies.鈥 The top three most reported reasons for these challenges were 鈥渓imited product availability,鈥 鈥渟hipment delays,鈥 鈥渙rders arriving with missing items, reduced quantities, or product substitutions.鈥

鈥淚 think we are continuing to be surprised by the range of experiences that schools are having to deal with as a result of COVID. It hasn鈥檛 subsided,鈥 Carr said. 鈥淚t is not over yet is what I believe these data are saying.鈥

]]>
Survey: Pandemic Learning Loss is Teachers鈥 Top Source of Job-Related Stress /article/survey-pandemic-learning-loss-is-teachers-top-source-of-job-related-stress/ Wed, 15 Jun 2022 04:01:00 +0000 /?post_type=article&p=691447 Educators experience more than twice as much job-related stress as other working adults, and about half of teachers say trying to help students make up for lost instructional time is their greatest source of anxiety, according to a new survey.

The Rand Corp. report shows this year has been especially tough on Latino teachers, with one in three reporting symptoms of depression, compared with one in four non-Latino teachers. Black teachers, however, were less likely to report stress on the job than White and Latino teachers, the researchers found.

鈥淩epairing鈥 teacher and principal well-being, they wrote, 鈥渋s essential for pandemic recovery鈥 and leaders shouldn鈥檛 view it as a short-term problem that will fade once COVID-related disruptions pass.

鈥淪tress on the job can negatively affect educators鈥 physical health,鈥 said Elizabeth Steiner, lead author of the report. 鈥淎nd poor well-being is linked with lower quality student learning.鈥

While most educators 鈥 about three-fourths 鈥 say they鈥檙e able to cope with the added pressures, the findings reinforce comments from teachers who say this school year has been the most grueling since the pandemic began. The Rand findings echo the results of a Gallup poll released this week and confirm earlier surveys suggesting sizable percentages of teachers want to leave the profession. The Rand survey shows about a third of educators report plans to quit 鈥 up from a quarter of teachers and 15% of principals in January 2021.


Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for 麻豆精品 Newsletter


The findings point to multiple factors contributing to job dissatisfaction and intentions to leave. In addition to addressing learning loss, other pandemic-related stressors included taking on additional responsibilities because of staff shortages, harassment over COVID policies and balancing child care responsibilities.

But some sources of stress, such as racial discrimination, predate COVID. More than half of teachers said other staff members hold them to a different standard because of their race, and two-thirds of principals said they have faced online or in-person harassment from students鈥 families because of their race or ethnicity.

Almost half of teachers said they experience verbal or nonverbal microaggressions from co-workers and students because of their race or ethnicity. (Rand Corp.)

Staying 鈥榩ast the burnout stage鈥

The increase in teachers saying they want to leave doesn鈥檛 mean they will, nor does it predict 鈥渁 major disruption in the workforce,鈥 the authors wrote. But Colin Sharkey, executive director of the Association of American Educators, a nonunion group, said an exodus of teachers could be a 鈥渓agging indicator.鈥

鈥嬧嬧滻t will take time for educators to follow through on a decision that was likely made during this time period,鈥 he said, adding that many educators might stay 鈥減ast the burnout stage,鈥 to the point that they鈥檙e 鈥渦nrecoverable.鈥

The Rand findings are based on responses from 2,360 teachers and 1,540 principals, collected in January. The researchers compared the answers to those from a nationally representative sample of working adults. They also interviewed 60 teachers to better understand their experiences.

Roseangela Mendoza, a middle school social studies teacher at The Ethical Community Charter School in Jersey City, New Jersey, is among those who found the return to in-person learning particularly challenging.

鈥淲e were exhausted by October鈥 of 2021, she said. 鈥淚t鈥檚 been the worst stress that anybody has ever gone through.鈥

Teaching assistants have been covering classes when teachers are absent, leaving lead teachers without their usual support, Mendoza said, adding that students, who learned remotely for a year and a half have trouble staying focused and are always bouncing out of their seats to socialize or go to the bathroom.

鈥淭hey will question you, 鈥榃hy do I have to do this?鈥 鈥 she said. Parents also challenge her, asking that their children get extra time to complete work. 鈥淭ons of parents want to tell us what we have to do.鈥

But she says she still believes in the mission of her school, which she joined not long after it opened in 2009, and likes that she can be creative in planning curriculum. Her lessons include making tortillas and quilting.

鈥淭hat flexibility is what keeps me here,鈥 she said.

Roseangela Mendoza, who teaches social studies, said flexibility over curriculum is what keeps her at The Ethical Community Charter School in Jersey City, New Jersey. (Courtesy of Roseangela Mendoza)

The report also points to conditions that make educators feel better about their jobs and less likely to leave, such as involvement in school decision-making, strong relationships with colleagues and access to mental health support.

Teachers and principals with access to at least one mental health program, such as a peer support group or counseling, were significantly less likely to say they were considering leaving their jobs, the survey found.

Many districts have been using federal relief funds to address students鈥 mental health needs, but some are expanding services for staff as well. The Moore Public Schools, near Oklahoma City, used a new state grant program to add eight positions for mental health professionals, including two employee assistance providers.

The district revamped an unused building into offices with private entrances where employees can see a therapist.

鈥淚 think it’s pretty rare,鈥 said Kristi Hernandez, the district鈥檚 director of student services. 鈥淢ost schools partner with outside providers.鈥

Teachers also just want to focus on teaching and spend less time on other responsibilities , such as meetings and bus duty, the Rand researchers found. And in their interviews with teachers, they heard that pay raises wouldn鈥檛 necessarily reduce the stress, but could convince teachers to stay in the field.

Principals listed staffing challenges as their greatest source of stress. But some feel the worst of the pandemic is finally behind them.

Haines City High School Principal Adam Lane, Florida鈥檚 newly named Principal of the Year for secondary schools, with last year鈥檚 graduates. (Courtesy of Adam Lane)

鈥淎 year ago we were doing temperature checks. We were doing masks,鈥 said Adam Lane, principal at Haines City High School in central Florida, south of Orlando. 鈥淭he past two and a half years were the most challenging thing we鈥檝e ever had to deal with.鈥

He said he just attended a statewide administrators conference, where the mood had noticeably lifted.

鈥淲e were laughing, drinking, collaborating,鈥 he said. 鈥淓ven though it was stressful, it was so rewarding to make it through.鈥

]]>
Growing Fears in Schools About Looming 'Mass Exodus' of Principals This Summer /article/school-leaders-crisis-overwhelmed-by-mounting-mental-health-issues-public-distrust-mass-exodus-of-principals-could-be-coming/ Sun, 20 Feb 2022 16:01:00 +0000 /?post_type=article&p=585156 As Derek Forbes began his third pandemic school year as a high school principal in Washington state, he was facing an uptick in disruptive behavior 鈥 kids talking back to teachers, getting into disagreements with their peers. 

Perhaps, he thought, young people had lost some maturing time in pandemic isolation, since the behavior was more typical of younger students. Or maybe, like him, they were . 


Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for 麻豆精品 Newsletter


The mental health positions he鈥檇 posted stayed vacant for a fifth month. He and his principal colleagues in the Meridian School District were now logging upwards of 60 hours a week, taking on responsibilities of counselors, nurses, subbing as teachers, and food service workers. All while being verbally attacked at local school board meetings over curricula and mask guidelines. 

Derek Forbes

鈥淢y students aren’t learning the way I want them to, they’re dealing with their own mental health issues that I can’t help them with, my staff are struggling with those same things. And more and more stuff just continues to pile on,鈥 he said. 

For the first time in his 22-year education career, a depleted Forbes has thought about leaving the job he loves, to pursue district leadership. 

鈥淚 always thought that I would always stay in education, and I have no doubt that I will continue鈥 But, I thought about what else might be out there. And I never thought I would do that,鈥 he said.

His experience is hardly rare. Across the country, many principals are preparing to leave the field altogether. 

A of more than 500 this fall by the National Association of Secondary School Principals has found nearly four in ten expect to leave their post within the next three years. More than a third will leave education as soon as they can find a higher-paying job. 

Dubbed a looming 鈥渕ass exodus鈥 by NASSP, numbers were even higher for principals with four years or less on the job: 62 percent of early-career principals said they will leave within the next six years. Many others are .

The crisis has hit principals of color, women and those leading schools with higher proportions of lower-income students and students of color particularly hard. They are more likely than their peers to experience job-related stress during the pandemic, a new study found. 

According to NASSP鈥檚 fall survey, 91 percent of principals were very or extremely concerned about student wellness, more than any other challenge (in comparison, mask mandates had about 51 percent very or extremely concerned). More than a third said there鈥檚 not adequate student services staff, like nurses and counselors.

鈥…For people to start saying, 鈥楳an, you know, I’m not ready to die. I’m not dying yet but this thing is killing me,鈥 really scares me,鈥 said NASSP CEO Ronn Nozoe. 鈥淏ecause people, especially our members, don’t say that stuff. And they don’t say it lightly and they sure as heck don’t say it publicly.鈥

RAND

The surveys and widespread stories of principals鈥 well-being plummeting point to the need for mental health support, mentorship and leadership development programs for principals, said Nozoe. 

Principals told 麻豆精品 the exodus may begin as early as the end of this school year. Some may want to leave mid-year but, understanding the stress it would cause for their schools, are waiting until summer break. 

Nozoe has seen red flags for the profession throughout the pandemic: Fewer candidates are entering training, higher education and . Superintendents are also experiencing burnout and reaching retirement, so some principals will go on to district roles.

But the biggest flag, he said, is that teachers across the country have expressed the same care and concern that they express for students, now for their supervisors. 

鈥淚t’s the first time I’ve really seen it – our teachers saying, 鈥榃e’re struggling, but man, I’m really worried about our principal,鈥欌 said Nozoe.

鈥溾楬e or she is getting beat up, and he doesn鈥檛 look good or she doesn’t look good. They’re all stressed out and I don’t want to lose her or him.鈥欌

Strategizing on how to better support students and staff mental health has had a ripple effect. Principals are now pointing the spotlight on themselves, taking stock of their own well-being.

鈥淚 have sought out and have been seeing a therapist, because I think it’s important 鈥 not just for me as a principal to talk to my kids about [their] mental health 鈥 it’s also important for me to walk that walk,鈥 said Michael Brown, president-elect of NASSP鈥檚 Maryland chapter and principal at Winter Mills High School. 

Brown said the 鈥渉ighly politicized nature of education鈥 has taken its toll on the state鈥檚 educators, many of whom never fully clock-out, making evening calls and communications about the latest pandemic guidance to families. 鈥淵ou struggle to have positive days, positive thoughts.鈥

鈥業 had to choose myself鈥

Nadia Lopez, former principal of the Mott Hall Bridges Academy, a middle school in Brooklyn鈥檚 Brownsville neighborhood, criticized the lack of support for principals of color during the pandemic and constant race-based violence.

While trying to keep students on track academically, their schools were disproportionately taxed by racism, police brutality, COVID-19 deaths and pandemic job loss. 

鈥淣ot once was there a convening of leaders to say 鈥榳e recognize that there’s an issue that’s happening across our nation, and you all are having to shoulder a lot of this,鈥欌 said Lopez.

Nadia Lopez with two former students at Mott Hall Bridges Academy in Brownsville, Brooklyn.

Now a leadership coach, she continually sees the impact of unsupportive superintendents and disproportionately concentrated student needs. On New Year鈥檚 Eve, she got a call from one distraught New York assistant principal of color, who regularly subbed for teachers on top of her usual duties. She was finally signing her resignation papers, accepting another offer. Another in California left her post mid-year to become a consultant. 

They and dozens of others have recounted their health issues, insomnia and depression to Lopez, their mentor who鈥檇 the Brooklyn middle school she founded and led for a decade. She resigned in June 2020 after developing a crippling kidney disease from the professional stress.

鈥淚 had to choose myself and say, this no longer aligns with who I am as a person. It doesn’t represent who I am as a parent. It doesn’t represent the leader that I’ve been to my scholars and telling them that education is a form of liberation,鈥 Lopez told the 74. 鈥淚t perpetuates the idea that you accept abuse when you shouldn’t have to.鈥

Clear across the country, educators in Wyoming are tapping out, too. 

This school year alone, Principal Brian Cox has hired seven new teachers; at least two 鈥渓eft the field of education altogether, mid-year.鈥 His workday starts at 2:30am to address daily staffing challenges. 

鈥淪ome principals feel like the job is becoming untenable. Like there is no way to win,鈥 said Cox, who heads up Cheyenne鈥檚 only predominantly low-income middle school. 

With media and public officials disrespecting their expertise, those in the profession feel, 鈥渓ike your boss had it out for you, the community hated you for the job you do,鈥 he said. The fallout will create amassive void 鈥 of interventions, of instructional and behavioral frameworks.鈥

Strengthening the pipeline

Top of mind for all principals 麻豆精品 interviewed is creating more balanced workloads, to change the reality that they cannot succeed without sacrificing their own health. 

States must also back ways to recruit and the next generation of teachers and administrators, Brown said. Investing funds in teacher retention alone will not have the domino effect it once had. 

鈥淭hey think it’s just going to be a natural pipeline. But if you see somebody leave鈥 it’s going to give people hesitation鈥︹業’m not exactly sure now, because this person, I really looked up to them鈥nd they weren’t able to handle it. How am I going to be able to handle it?鈥欌 Brown said. 

Principals on the brink are also looking for more support from states to match students鈥 growing wellness needs, to provide services that go beyond what schools can offer, such as partnerships with licensed mental health providers or clinics. 

Having district leaders act as thought partners, who can help them manage shortages or partner with universities to rebuild educator pipelines, has become a priority for principals debating their futures, said Lopez. 

鈥淲e need to have good programs to teach them. We need to have good mentoring programs to support them. We need to have great support systems in the districts to do it,鈥 said Nozoe. 鈥淭hat all has its infrastructure, and you can’t just snap your fingers and build it.鈥

]]>