麻豆精品

Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for 麻豆精品 Newsletter

This story was originally published by . for their newsletters.

The primary for the state鈥檚 top K-12 schools job is in less than a month, but judging from the polls, it鈥檚 debatable whether anyone is paying attention.

A whopping 32% of voters are undecided with just a few weeks until the for state superintendent of public instruction, according to by the Public Policy Institute of California. In the past, it鈥檚 been one of the state鈥檚 hottest races, with millions of dollars in spending.

Among the dozen or so candidates, none had more than 10% of voters鈥� support, meaning that the race is essentially a 10-way tie.

鈥淭here鈥檚 no lack of qualified candidates, but previous elections had an urgency and a sense that who won really mattered,鈥� said Morgan Polikoff, an education professor at USC. 鈥淲e don鈥檛 have that this time.鈥�

A job with few duties?

One reason for the malaise, observers said, may be that voters are more focused on education policy unfolding in Washington, D.C. The Trump administration is in the process of dismantling the U.S. Department of Education, which could potentially upend funding and student rights. Another reason might be that most of the candidates agree on the major issues, so there鈥檚 not much to distinguish them.

Regardless, the position might be nearly irrelevant by the time the new superintendent takes office. The state is poised to . Gov. Gavin Newsom proposed in January that the superintendent no longer run the California Department of Education. Instead, it would fall under the control of the State Board of Education, which is appointed by the governor. The idea was introduced in his January budget proposal and is expected to pass the Legislature.

That would shift power over the state鈥檚 10,000 public schools to the governor鈥檚 office. The superintendent would have few responsibilities except championing various education-related causes. The governor鈥檚 race would carry more relevance to school funding, policies and other issues than the superintendent鈥檚 race.

Teachers union weighs in

The California Teachers Association, one of the biggest players in education politics, has been far more involved in the governor鈥檚 race than the superintendent race. After Rep. Eric Swalwell dropped out of the governor鈥檚 race, the union endorsed billionaire Tom Steyer for governor, citing his alignment with the union鈥檚 priorities.

For superintendent, the union endorsed Richard Barrera, a San Diego Unified school board member who was little known outside San Diego before winning the union鈥檚 backing.

鈥淭he superintendent race is off the radar because the governor鈥檚 race has taken up so much bandwidth,鈥� said David Goldberg, president of the union. 鈥淎lthough the superintendent鈥檚 impact is deeply felt by those who work in public education, it鈥檚 not widely known outside public education.鈥�

The next superintendent will replace Tony Thurmond, who is termed out and is running for governor. The superintendent position is nonpartisan and pays . The top two candidates in June鈥檚 primary will advance to the November general election.

So far, the leading candidates in the superintendent鈥檚 race include a host of education policy veterans. Among them: Assemblymember Al Muratsuchi, former head of the Assembly education committee; Josh Newman, former head of the Senate education committee; Anthony Rendon, former speaker of the Assembly and a longtime early education program administrator; and Nichelle Henderson, a Los Angeles Community College District board member.

鈥楢 lightning rod鈥�

Sonja Shaw, a school board member in Chino Valley, is also running and has gained traction on the right. In the most recent poll, she had support from 7% of voters, the same as Barrera. Lance Christensen, who ran against Thurmond in 2022, predicted that Shaw will advance to the November election because Democrats鈥� votes will split among the other candidates.

Shaw is best known for her fiery positions on transgender student rights. She was propelled to the limelight in 2023 when she presided over a Chino Valley school board meeting where out when he spoke over his time limit defending transgender students鈥� right to privacy. She鈥檚 been an outspoken advocate for schools to inform parents if their child identifies as transgender, and for students to participate on teams that align with their gender at birth.

鈥淭hey can say anything they want about her, but she鈥檚 such a lightning rod that now everyone knows who she is,鈥� said Christensen, who鈥檚 now a vice president at the anti-union California Policy Center. 鈥淚 think this issue will take her all the way to Sacramento.鈥�

Why no one鈥檚 talking about charter schools

One issue that鈥檚 been glaringly absent in the superintendent race is charter schools. In years past, charter schools were the No. 1 topic in the race. Candidates were deemed to be either 鈥減ro-charter鈥� or 鈥渁nti-charter,鈥� with donations and rhetoric following suit. 鈥淧ro-charter鈥� was often interpreted to mean anti-union, leading to an avalanche of rancor from both sides.

But the public, and even the unions, seem to have grown tired of arguing about the independent public schools. One reason is that many charter schools now have unions. Another reason is that because of declining enrollment, charter schools are no longer expanding; they appear to have plateaued at about 10% of overall enrollment.

A more likely reason is that voters see that charter schools and traditional public schools grapple with the same issues, said Marshall Tuck, a former chief executive of the Green Dot charter school network who ran for superintendent in 2018 and 2014. The 2018 election in which he lost to Thurmond was one of the most costly superintendent races ever, with contributions topping $50 million. By comparison, no candidate in the current election has raised more than $1 million so far.

Most schools 鈥� regardless of their governance structure 鈥� are facing , and lackluster student engagement since the pandemic ended.

鈥淣ow that we鈥檝e removed the charter vitriol, we can focus on bigger issues,鈥� said Tuck, who is now chief executive at EdVoice, a policy advocacy organization. 鈥淭he core issues are the same everywhere.鈥�

This article was and was republished under the license.

Did you use this article in your work?

We鈥檇 love to hear how 麻豆精品鈥檚 reporting is helping educators, researchers, and policymakers.