麻豆精品

Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for 麻豆精品 Newsletter

Standardized testing has long been the gold standard of student success. Large-scale assessments give districts a big-picture view of student progress, offering convenient data points to compare performance, identify trends and demonstrate accountability.

But numbers can only tell part of the story. They never capture the child behind the score 鈥� the effort behind mastering a difficult concept, the pride of discovering their passion for history through a hands-on project, or the confidence that grows with every hard-earned breakthrough. We risk devaluing individual learning every time we celebrate a rise in collective scores.

While standardized assessments remain a traditional foundational measure of progress, achievement can no longer be dictated by these metrics alone. Over and over, research shows that high-stakes testing students and teachers and down to math and reading scores.

But we hold on to them because familiar systems are easier to defend than reinvent.

Thankfully, the tide is turning. As the framework gains momentum across the U.S., schools are primed to completely reimagine how we measure learning in a way that is authentic to the human experience and to select tools that support, rather than complicate, the work of capturing future-ready skills. 

One of the most harmful effects of schools’ over-reliance on standardized testing is that students leave unprepared for life after graduation. 

Instead of empowering students with the skills to navigate a complex world, educators are forced to 鈥渢each to the test,鈥� prioritizing performance on a single test over deep learning to satisfy accountability measures for policymakers and legislators.

Our students鈥� future success depends on more than reversing in reading and math. According to America Succeeds, most requested skills by employers are durable skills, such as effective communication, creativity and critical thinking developed through real-world, authentic learning experiences. 

However, the found that 84% of hiring managers say most high school graduates are not prepared for the workforce, and 80% believe they are less prepared than previous generations.

As educators, we have a moral obligation to ensure we are preparing students for the future. That means looking beyond a single standardized score as proof of readiness, toward multiple measures that capture the whole child. Traditional measures still have a place, but they can’t be the only way to assess a student. 

Districts that implement a Portrait of a Graduate initiative define the competencies they value and want every student to leave with 鈥� qualities like emotional intelligence, adaptability, collaboration and resilience. However, many struggle to put operations in place that turn aspirations from a poster on the wall into a fully functional system that monitors student progress and success. 

The result is predictable: 160 schools deliver 160 different experiences. This lack of systemic cohesion ensures that access to transformative opportunities remains uneven, directly impacting student outcomes.

When its accountability framework this past spring, districts gained the structural flexibility to look beyond rigid standardized ratings. By introducing local indicators of quality alongside state metrics, the state is empowering schools to demonstrate student growth through capstone projects, performance-based defenses and real-world learning aligned with the Portrait of a Learner framework adopted in 2022.

into this opportunity early through a simple, yet transformative shift: engaging community stakeholders from day one to co-create implementation playbooks, establish shared guidelines, define common rubrics, and run pilot programs that validate these authentic assessments of learning.

This collaborative approach helped school leaders ensure consistent experiences in all classrooms while still empowering teachers with the freedom to tailor instruction to students鈥� needs. Most importantly, the values became embedded in each district鈥檚 culture, from the district office down to each and every student.

For districts leading the work, technology that supports tracking and reporting on student skills is critical. They can no longer adopt one-size-fits-all tools when the goal is communicating highly personalized progress that reveals a student’s true capabilities. It’s more important than ever to evaluate every tool line by line against district initiatives and ensure a match.

The most effective empower teachers and students to collect and showcase meaningful artifacts of learning through the educational journey, including capstone projects, student reflections, work samples and project portfolios. At the same time, they must offer robust rubric assessments so that teachers can clearly identify when a student falls short of a benchmark 鈥� and where extra support may be needed to help strengthen durable skills needed for the real world. 

With these insights, schools no longer hold students accountable to a single, high-stakes measure of learning. Instead, they create multiple opportunities for growth. 

Society champions second chances as stepping stones: Drivers-to-be can retake their driving test, law school graduates can sit for the bar exam multiple times. Yet, we often tell a 15-year-old that their years of learning can be distilled into one test score. Students should be given opportunities to learn from their setbacks, to revise and resubmit work and to re-demonstrate mastery of content without judgement.

When we finally shift our focus from proving learning to nurturing it, we create spaces where every child has the chance to thrive.

As educators, we know when learning happens 鈥� we don鈥檛 need numbers to tell us. We know it when the shy student steps confidently in front of the class to deliver a presentation. We know it when a group of students tackle a complex, real-world problem together. But too often, these moments of learning are invisible to accountability systems that prioritize hard numbers over growth.

By measuring student progress through multiple forms of evidence 鈥� capturing not only academic achievement but also future-ready competencies 鈥� we honor students not just for what they know but for who they are becoming.

Dr. Terra Greenwell is an Educational Leadership and Systems Advisor, and former Chief Academic Officer for Jefferson County Public Schools.

Did you use this article in your work?

We鈥檇 love to hear how 麻豆精品鈥檚 reporting is helping educators, researchers, and policymakers.